Integrating human rights into development cooperation: empirical findings from the right to water

From WaterWiki.net

Jump to: navigation, search
edit  ·  Toolkit Human Rights-Based Approach (HRBA) to Water Governance
UNDP Regional HRBA to Water Programme for Europe & CIS

Detailed documentation: Background | Regional aspects | Regional Programme | Methodology
PHASE 1: Checklist (Bosnia and Herzegovina | Georgia | Moldova | Tajikistan | Turkey | Ukraine)
PHASE 2: Country Sector Assessments and Proposed Projects (Bosnia and Herzegovina | Tajikistan | Kosovo | Serbia) | Bibliography

Legal Framework: The Rights to Water and Sanitation in International Law | Regional Law | National Law
WaterWiki-resources:Rights to Water and Sanitation: A Handbook for Activists | UN Human Rights Council Resolution on Water and Sanitation | UN Recognises Access to Clean Water as a Basic Human Right | Human Rights-Based Approach | Applying a HRBA to Water:A Case Study | Water-related Legislation and Conventions | The Right to Water - WHO Publication | A UN Convention on the Right to Water - An Idea Whose Time Has Come | International Conference on the Right to Water and Sanitation in Theory and Practice | Q&A: The Right to Water | General Comment 15 (2002) | Q&A: Water Governance | Water and Health | Equitable Access to Water and Human Rights | European Union Water Framework Directive | Essay: What exactly is “The Right to Water”? | Protocol on Water and Health | Protocol on Water and Health/Q&A | Lessons Learned From Rights-Based Approaches in the Asia-Pacific Region | Human Rights-Based Approach Strategies adopted by UNICEF Laos | Utility Privatisation through the Lens of Human Rights | The Right to Water - From Concept to Implementation | The Human Right to Water:Translating Theory into Practice | Report of the Seminar on Human Rights and MDGs, May 2009
External resources: HRBA and Water Governance Fast Facts - UNDP | Applying a HRBA to Developing Cooperation and Programming (UNDP, 2006) | COHRE Manual on the Right to Water and Sanitation | Protocol on Water and Health - Full Document) | COHRE Monitoring Implementation of the Right to Water: A Framework for Developing Indicators | Sub-commission guidelines for the realisation of the right to drinking water and sanitation (2005) | UNFPA - A HRBA to Programming, Practical Implementation Manual and Training Materials (2010) | Operational Guidelines for Implementing a Rights-Based Approach in Water and Sanitation Programming (CoHRE,2008) | COHRE Monitoring Implementation of the Right to Water: A Framework for Developing Indicators | FAQs on a HRBA to Development Cooperation | The Human Rights-Based Approach to Development - The Right to Water | UN Independent Expert Report on the issue of human rights obligations related to water and sanitation 2009 | UN Independent Expert Report on MDGs and right to water and sanitation 2010
Websites: The Rights to Water and Sanitation Information Portal | UN Independent Expert on Right to Water and Sanitation Webpage

Publication Title

Empirical reflections on the role of human rights in development discourse at the international level: a case study of the the right to water

Publication Type

Author(s)

Dr. Anna Russell, Oxford Centre for Water Research, University of Oxford

Publication Date

26 Nov 2008

ISBN-ISSN-EAN

Publication URL

Contact

Contents

Summary

Historically, the field of international development has been disconnected - both in theory and in practice - from the field of international human rights. Development specialists have traditionally worked in isolation from human rights advocates. Since the 1990s, there has been a convergence of these fields and the two communities have begun to interact more closely. However, while the two fields are now being labeled as ‘mutually reinforcing’, there remains a lack of empirical research examining the entry of human rights into the development sector.


After tracing the historical interaction between these two fields, this paper examines the current role of human rights in development discourse at the international level. Using the right to water as a case study, an empirical investigation was conducted into how various groups (international organizations, non-governmental organizations and transnational corporations) understand and use human rights in the context of international development discourse. A qualitative methodology consisting of documentation review and interviews of key informants was used.


Based on the three groups examined, in international development discourse, the right to water is often seen as a theoretical construct and having little influence on improving universal access to basic services. Alternatively, or sometimes simultaneously, it is seen as simply a development outcome. While significant resistance to the incorporation of rights language into the sector was visible, there was some attraction to its inherent advocacy and empowerment potential through its associated notions of entitlement. Organizations which use the right to water tend to do so to spark political mobilization around water access issues. In doing so, in the development context, the right to water has become loosely equated with any number of vague principles of participation, non-discrimination, access to information etc. International human rights in development discourse have become disassociated from legal obligations and normative standards. This paper therefore calls for a re-injection of reference to the international human rights framework when integrating rights into development cooperation - both within and beyond the water sector.

References

See also

HRBA

Q&A: The Right to Water

External Resources

Attachments

3477 Rating: 2.5/5 (25 votes cast)